Why can’t attribute names be Python keywords?

by

Because parser is simpler when keywords are always keywords, and not contextual (e.g. if is a keyword when on the statement level, but just an identifier when inside an expression — for if it’d be double hard because of X if C else Y, and for is used in list comprehensions and generator expressions).

So the code doesn’t even get to the point where there’s attribute access, it’s simply rejected by the parser, just like incorrect indentation (which is why it’s a SyntaxError, and not AttributeError or something). It doesn’t differentiate whether you use if as an attribute name, a variable name, a function name, or a type name. It can never be an identifier, simply because parser always assigns it “keyword” label and makes it a different token than identifiers.

It’s the same in most languages, and language grammar (+ lexer specification) is the documentation for that. Language spec mentions it explicitly. It also doesn’t change in Python 3.

Also, just because you can use setattr or __dict__ to make an attribute with a reserved name, doesn’t mean you should. Don’t force yourself/API user to use getattr instead of natural attribute access. getattr should be reserved for when access to a variable attribute name is needed.

More Related Contents:

  1. How do you programmatically set an attribute?
  2. Accessing dict keys like an attribute?
  3. Python function attributes – uses and abuses [closed]
  4. Getting attributes of a class
  5. Python string to attribute
  6. syntax error when using command line in python
  7. correct way to define class variables in Python [duplicate]
  8. Why is adding attributes to an already instantiated object allowed?
  9. Why can’t you add attributes to object in python? [duplicate]
  10. Set attributes from dictionary in python
  11. How can a function access its own attributes?
  12. Python print statement “Syntax Error: invalid syntax” [duplicate]
  13. Difference between methods and attributes in python
  14. In class object, how to auto update attributes?
  15. How to solve SyntaxError on autogenerated manage.py?
  16. AttributeError: partially initialized module ‘turtle’ has no attribute ‘Turtle’ (most likely due to a circular import)
  17. Error “(unicode error) ‘unicodeescape’ codec can’t decode bytes in position 2-3: truncated \UXXXXXXXX escape” [duplicate]
  18. Why doesn’t 2.__add__(3) work in Python?
  19. How to access (get or set) object attribute given string corresponding to name of that attribute
  20. Why am I getting “invalid syntax” from an f-string? [duplicate]
  21. hasattr() vs try-except block to deal with non-existent attributes
  22. Why does the IPython REPL tell me “SyntaxError: unexpected EOF while parsing” as I input the code?
  23. How do I set permissions (attributes) on a file in a ZIP file using Python’s zipfile module?
  24. Invalid Syntax error when running python from inside Visual Studio Code
  25. “EOL while scanning single-quoted string”? (backslash in string) [duplicate]
  26. Python matplotlib decrease size of colorbar labels
  27. getattr and setattr on nested subobjects / chained properties?
  28. Attributes initialization/declaration in Python class: where to place them?
  29. How to declare a static attribute in Python?
  30. How to fix syntax error when printing a string with an apostrophe in it? [closed]

Leave a Comment