Why does Go allow compilation of unused function parameters?

by

There’s no official reason, but the reason given on golang-nuts is:

Unused variables are always a programming error, whereas it is common
to write a function that doesn’t use all of its arguments.

One could leave those arguments unnamed (using _), but then that might
confuse with functions like

func foo(_ string, _ int) // what’s this supposed to do?

The names, even if they’re unused, provide important documentation.

Andrew

https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/golang-nuts/q09H61oxwWw

Sometimes having unused parameters is important for satisfying interfaces, one example might be a function that operates on a weighted graph. If you want to implement a graph with a uniform cost across all edges, it’s useless to consider the nodes:

func (graph *MyGraph) Distance(node1,node2 Node) int {
    return 1
}

As that thread notes, there is a valid argument to only allow parameters named as _ if they’re unused (e.g. Distance(_,_ Node)), but at this point it’s too late due to the Go 1 future-compatibility guarantee. As also mentioned, a possible objection to that anyway is that parameters, even if unused, can implicitly provide documentation.

In short: there’s no concrete, specific answer, other than that they simply made an ultimately arbitrary (but still educated) determination that unused parameters are more important and useful than unused local variables and imports. If there was once a strong design reason, it’s not documented anywhere.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why there are two ways of declaring variables in Go, what’s the difference and which to use?
  2. What is “_,” (underscore comma) in a Go declaration?
  3. Creating or referencing variables dynamically in Sass
  4. What’s the difference between placing “mut” before a variable name and after the “:”?
  5. Error if don’t check if {{object.field}} exists
  6. When should an Excel VBA variable be killed or set to Nothing?
  7. What does go build build? (go build vs. go install)
  8. HiveQL: Using query results as variables
  9. Dynamically create variables in PowerShell
  10. PHP check whether property exists in object or class
  11. setq and defvar in Lisp
  12. Can I make a plpgsql function return an integer without using a variable?
  13. What is the difference between a member variable and a local variable?
  14. LessCss dynamic variables based on ancestor class
  15. Is it possible to create a multi-line string variable in a Makefile
  16. Powershell pass variable to start-job
  17. go build works fine but go run fails
  18. Batch File Set Variable not working [duplicate]
  19. Determine variable names dynamically according to a string in Fortran
  20. Comparing IEEE floats and doubles for equality
  21. Why are variables “i” and “j” used for counters?
  22. Windows Batch files: what is variable expansion, and what does EnableDelayedExpansion mean?
  23. What is the difference between a constant and a static variable and which should I choose?
  24. What is the order of local variables on the stack?
  25. Set fact with dynamic key name in ansible
  26. Declaring global variable with php.ini
  27. Create a variable in swift with dynamic name
  28. Finding out reason of Pyomo model infeasibility
  29. When should I quote CMake variable references?
  30. How to pass a variable to the SelectCommand of a SqlDataSource?

Leave a Comment