Why don’t languages raise errors on integer overflow by default?

by

In C#, it was a question of performance. Specifically, out-of-box benchmarking.

When C# was new, Microsoft was hoping a lot of C++ developers would switch to it. They knew that many C++ folks thought of C++ as being fast, especially faster than languages that “wasted” time on automatic memory management and the like.

Both potential adopters and magazine reviewers are likely to get a copy of the new C#, install it, build a trivial app that no one would ever write in the real world, run it in a tight loop, and measure how long it took. Then they’d make a decision for their company or publish an article based on that result.

The fact that their test showed C# to be slower than natively compiled C++ is the kind of thing that would turn people off C# quickly. The fact that your C# app is going to catch overflow/underflow automatically is the kind of thing that they might miss. So, it’s off by default.

I think it’s obvious that 99% of the time we want /checked to be on. It’s an unfortunate compromise.

More Related Contents:

  1. Conventions for exceptions or error codes [closed]
  2. What is an integer overflow error?
  3. What is the difference between a deep copy and a shallow copy?
  4. What is the difference between concurrency and parallelism?
  5. Why shouldn’t I use “Hungarian Notation”?
  6. Expression Versus Statement
  7. Are there any legitimate use-cases for “goto” in a language that supports loops and functions?
  8. Prefer composition over inheritance?
  9. Singletons: good design or a crutch? [closed]
  10. Which, and why, do you prefer Exceptions or Return codes?
  11. Buffered vs unbuffered IO
  12. Efficient unsigned-to-signed cast avoiding implementation-defined behavior
  13. Are circular class dependencies bad from a coding style point of view? [closed]
  14. Allen Holub wrote “You should never use get/set functions”, is he correct? [duplicate]
  15. What are the lesser known but useful data structures?
  16. What is a Lambda?
  17. Semantic Diff Utilities [closed]
  18. Why is it recommended to have empty line in the end of a source file?
  19. Are exceptions really for exceptional errors? [closed]
  20. Generate colors between red and green for a power meter?
  21. How are mutexes implemented?
  22. Calculating a 2D Vector’s Cross Product
  23. How can I detect integer overflow on 32 bits int?
  24. What’s the shortest code to cause a stack overflow? [closed]
  25. Hash Code and Checksum – what’s the difference?
  26. In what situations is octal base used?
  27. When should a method be static?
  28. How to design extensible software (plugin architecture)? [closed]
  29. XOR of three values
  30. String Compare “Logic”

Leave a Comment