Why is conversion from string constant to ‘char*’ valid in C but invalid in C++

by

Up through C++03, your first example was valid, but used a deprecated implicit conversion–a string literal should be treated as being of type char const *, since you can’t modify its contents (without causing undefined behavior).

As of C++11, the implicit conversion that had been deprecated was officially removed, so code that depends on it (like your first example) should no longer compile.

You’ve noted one way to allow the code to compile: although the implicit conversion has been removed, an explicit conversion still works, so you can add a cast. I would not, however, consider this “fixing” the code.

Truly fixing the code requires changing the type of the pointer to the correct type:

char const *p = "abc"; // valid and safe in either C or C++.

As to why it was allowed in C++ (and still is in C): simply because there’s a lot of existing code that depends on that implicit conversion, and breaking that code (at least without some official warning) apparently seemed to the standard committees like a bad idea.

More Related Contents:

  1. The array index doesnt show the character [closed]
  2. How to convert a std::string to const char* or char*
  3. Legality of COW std::string implementation in C++11
  4. Converting std::__cxx11::string to std::string
  5. Is a string literal in С++ created in static memory?
  6. Conveniently Declaring Compile-Time Strings in C++
  7. Will std::string always be null-terminated in C++11?
  8. std::string to char*
  9. How to return a std::string.c_str()
  10. Is string::c_str() no longer null terminated in C++11?
  11. Why does streaming a char pointer to cout not print an address?
  12. Split a string using C++11
  13. Conversion from string literal to char* is deprecated
  14. How do I properly use std::string on UTF-8 in C++?
  15. Set precision of std::to_string when converting floating point values [duplicate]
  16. Deprecated conversion from string literal to ‘char*’
  17. Why is modifying a string through a retrieved pointer to its data not allowed?
  18. cannot convert ‘std::basic_string’ to ‘const char*’ for argument ‘1’ to ‘int system(const char*)’
  19. How to convert a char array to a string?
  20. C++: Can a macro expand “abc” into ‘a’, ‘b’, ‘c’?
  21. Convert between string, u16string & u32string
  22. How can I create a string from a single character?
  23. Is writing to &str[0] buffer (of a std:string) well-defined behaviour in C++11?
  24. “to_string” isn’t a member of “std”?
  25. What is the simplest way to convert char[] to/from tchar[] in C/C++(ms)?
  26. strcmp or string::compare?
  27. C++ Passing std::string by reference to function in dll
  28. Concatenate compile-time strings in a template at compile time?
  29. Assign a string literal to a char* [duplicate]
  30. String Literal address across translation units [duplicate]

Leave a Comment