a class-key must be declared when declaring a friend

by

I was surprised about this (and as a result deleted a previous incorrect answer). The C++03 standard says in 11.4:

An elaborated-type-specifier shall be used in a friend declaration for a class.

Then to make sure there’s no misunderstanding, it footnotes that with:

The class-key of the elaborated-type-specifier is required.

GCC is the only compiler that I have that complains about the missing class-key, but it looks like other compilers are letting us get away with something non-standard…

Now as for the rationale – you’d have to ask someone who knows more about compilers (or standards) than I do.

More Related Contents:

  1. Friend function strange behaviour
  2. overloading friend operator
  3. When should you use ‘friend’ in C++?
  4. Can we increase the re-usability of this key-oriented access-protection pattern?
  5. What’s the scope of inline friend functions?
  6. How to declare a templated struct/class as a friend?
  7. Is this key-oriented access-protection pattern a known idiom?
  8. Access friend function defined in class
  9. How can I remove/refactor a «friend» dependency declaration properly?
  10. Are inner classes in C++ automatically friends?
  11. Error with multiple definitions of function
  12. declare template friend function of template class
  13. ampersand (&) at the end of variable etc
  14. Friend scope in C++
  15. C++ template friend operator overloading
  16. Making a template parameter a friend?
  17. clean C++ granular friend equivalent? (Answer: Attorney-Client Idiom)
  18. Why does C++ not allow inherited friendship?
  19. ‘friend’ functions and
  20. friend AND inline method, what’s the point ?
  21. Overload operators as member function or non-member (friend) function?
  22. Why does a C++ friend class need a forward declaration only in other namespaces?
  23. How does the friend keyword (Class/Function) break encapsulation in C++?
  24. How to name this key-oriented access-protection pattern?
  25. Specify a class member function as a friend of another class?
  26. friend declaration declares a non-template function [duplicate]
  27. when g++ static link pthread, cause Segmentation fault, why?
  28. Range-based for loop on a dynamic array?
  29. Can I obtain C++ type names in a constexpr way?
  30. Compile-time constant id

Leave a Comment