Difference between rdtscp, rdtsc : memory and cpuid / rdtsc?

by

As mentioned in a comment, there’s a difference between a compiler barrier and a processor barrier. volatile and memory in the asm statement act as a compiler barrier, but the processor is still free to reorder instructions.

Processor barrier are special instructions that must be explicitly given, e.g. rdtscp, cpuid, memory fence instructions (mfence, lfence, …) etc.

As an aside, while using cpuid as a barrier before rdtsc is common, it can also be very bad from a performance perspective, since virtual machine platforms often trap and emulate the cpuid instruction in order to impose a common set of CPU features across multiple machines in a cluster (to ensure that live migration works). Thus it’s better to use one of the memory fence instructions.

The Linux kernel uses mfence;rdtsc on AMD platforms and lfence;rdtsc on Intel. If you don’t want to bother with distinguishing between these, mfence;rdtsc works on both although it’s slightly slower as mfence is a stronger barrier than lfence.

Edit 2019-11-25: As of Linux kernel 5.4, lfence is used to serialize rdtsc on both Intel and AMD. See this commit “x86: Remove X86_FEATURE_MFENCE_RDTSC”: https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git/commit/?id=be261ffce6f13229dad50f59c5e491f933d3167f

More Related Contents:

  1. How to get the CPU cycle count in x86_64 from C++?
  2. Why does C++ code for testing the Collatz conjecture run faster than hand-written assembly?
  3. Is < faster than
  4. What is IACA and how do I use it?
  5. Replacing a 32-bit loop counter with 64-bit introduces crazy performance deviations with _mm_popcnt_u64 on Intel CPUs
  6. Is inline assembly language slower than native C++ code?
  7. Using bts assembly instruction with gcc compiler
  8. Calculate system time using rdtsc
  9. Why is this SIMD multiplication not faster than non-SIMD multiplication?
  10. Why is this C++ wrapper class not being inlined away?
  11. Why C/C++ is slower than Assembly and other low level languages?
  12. Regarding time out in code
  13. How do you get assembler output from C/C++ source in gcc?
  14. Does the C++ standard mandate poor performance for iostreams, or am I just dealing with a poor implementation?
  15. Performance of built-in types : char vs short vs int vs. float vs. double
  16. Ternary operator ?: vs if…else
  17. while (1) Vs. for (;;) Is there a speed difference?
  18. How to Detect the Number of Physical Processors / Cores on Windows, Mac and Linux
  19. How do objects work in x86 at the assembly level?
  20. Efficient 128-bit addition using carry flag
  21. Is using double faster than float?
  22. Trial-division code runs 2x faster as 32-bit on Windows than 64-bit on Linux
  23. vector or map, which one to use?
  24. Performance issue for vector::size() in a loop in C++
  25. How to alpha blend RGBA unsigned byte color fast?
  26. Can const-correctness improve performance?
  27. Benefits of using reserve() in a vector – C++
  28. Which is faster/preferred: memset or for loop to zero out an array of doubles?
  29. C++ Serialization Performance
  30. Why is pow(int, int) so slow?

Leave a Comment