Explain why constructor inject is better than other options [duplicate]

by

A class that takes a required dependency as a constructor argument can only be instantiated if that argument is provided (you should have a guard clause to make sure the argument is not null) (or use a non-nullable type in Kotlin). A constructor therefore enforces the dependency requirement whether or not you’re using Spring, making it container-agnostic.

If you use setter injection, the setter may or may not be called, so the instance may never be provided with its dependency. The only way to force the setter to be called is using @Required or @Autowired
, which is specific to Spring and is therefore not container-agnostic.

So to keep your code independent of Spring, use constructor arguments for injection. This applies to tests; you’ll have an easier time instantiating and testing the class in a normal unit test, without needing to configure an application context or the complexity that comes along with setting up an integration test.

Update: Spring 4.3 will perform implicit injection in single-constructor scenarios, making your code more independent of Spring by potentially not requiring an @Autowired annotation at all.

More Related Contents:

  1. How can I inject a property value into a Spring Bean which was configured using annotations?
  2. ContextLoaderListener or not?
  3. @Resource vs @Autowired
  4. How to inject a Map using the @Value Spring Annotation?
  5. How to inject dependencies into a self-instantiated object in Spring?
  6. Self injection with Spring
  7. What is the difference between @Inject and @Autowired in Spring Framework? Which one to use under what condition?
  8. Spring Autowiring class vs. interface?
  9. Spring: Why do we autowire the interface and not the implemented class?
  10. exclude @Component from @ComponentScan
  11. Spring Qualifier and property placeholder
  12. Is spring default scope singleton or not?
  13. Spring – Injecting a dependency into a ServletContextListener
  14. Difference between @Bean and @Autowired
  15. Inject bean into enum
  16. Spring injection Into Servlet
  17. Using Spring 3 autowire in a standalone Java application
  18. How to get bean using application context in spring boot
  19. Spring @Autowired on a class new instance
  20. Autowiring in Spring bean (@Component) created with new keyword
  21. Spring annotation-based DI vs xml configuration?
  22. Spring Property Injection in a final attribute @Value – Java
  23. How to collect and inject all beans of a given type in Spring XML configuration
  24. Registering beans(prototype) at runtime in Spring
  25. Anyway to @Inject/@Autowire an inner class into an outer class?
  26. Spring JUnit: How to Mock autowired component in autowired component
  27. How to instantiate Spring managed beans at runtime?
  28. @Valid when creating objects with jackson without controller
  29. How to tell Jackson to ignore empty object during deserialization?
  30. How to specify prefix for all controllers in Spring Boot?

Leave a Comment