Why does char* cause undefined behaviour while char[] doesn’t?

by

Any attempt to modify a C string literal has undefined behaviour. A compiler may arrange for string literals to be stored in read-only memory (protected by the OS, not literally ROM unless you’re on an embedded system). But the language doesn’t require this; it’s up to you as a programmer to get it right.

A sufficiently clever compiler could have warned you that you should have declared the pointer as:

const char * p = "wikimedia";

though the declaration without the const is legal in C (for the sake of not breaking old code). But with or without a compiler warning, the const is a very good idea.

(In C++, the rules are different; C++ string literals, unlike C string literals, really are const.)

When you initialize an array with a literal, the literal itself still exists in a potentially read-only region of your program image, but it is copied into the local array:

char s[] = "wikimedia"; /* initializes the array with the bytes from the string */
char t[] = { 'w', 'i', ... 'a', 0 };  /* same thing */

Note that char u[] = *p does not work — arrays can only be initialized from a brace initializer, and char arrays additionally from a string literal.

More Related Contents:

  1. isnt everything where it should be, why the segmentation fault?
  2. Removing digits and all punctuation except apostrophe from a string in C
  3. returning string in C function [closed]
  4. What is the difference between char s[] and char *s?
  5. Why does strchr take an int for the char to be found?
  6. Return char[]/string from a function [duplicate]
  7. What is the proper way of implementing a good “itoa()” function?
  8. How does c compare character variable against string?
  9. Conversion of Char to Binary in C
  10. Does C have a string type? [closed]
  11. Counting number of occurrences of a char in a string in C
  12. C split a char array into different variables
  13. Reading newline from previous input when reading from keyboard with scanf()
  14. Assigning char array a value in C
  15. read specific number of chars in c [closed]
  16. (Why) is using an uninitialized variable undefined behavior?
  17. How do you allow spaces to be entered using scanf?
  18. Is char signed or unsigned by default?
  19. How to convert an int to string in C?
  20. Why is “a” != “a” in C?
  21. Is accessing a global array outside its bound undefined behavior?
  22. What does strcmp() exactly return in C?
  23. C strings confusion
  24. Char to int conversion in C
  25. undefined reference to `strlwr’
  26. In C, why can’t an integer value be assigned to an int* the same way a string value can be assigned to a char*?
  27. C Strings Comparison with Equal Sign
  28. realloc(): invalid next size when reallocating to make space for strcat on char * [duplicate]
  29. C code with undefined results, compiler generates invalid code (with -O3)
  30. printf() with no arguments in C compiles fine. how?

Leave a Comment