Why can’t Python increment variable in closure?

by

You can’t re-bind closure variables in Python 2. In Python 3, which you appear to be using due to your print(), you can declare them nonlocal:

def foo():

  counter = 1

  def bar():
    nonlocal counter
    counter += 1
    print("bar", counter)

  return bar

bar = foo()
bar()

Otherwise, the assignment within bar() makes the variable local, and since you haven’t assigned a value to the variable in the local scope, trying to access it is an error.

In Python 2, my favorite workaround looks like this:

def foo():

  class nonlocal:
    counter = 1

  def bar():
    nonlocal.counter += 1
    print("bar", nonlocal.counter)

  return bar

bar = foo()
bar()

This works because mutating a mutable object doesn’t require changing what the variable name points to. In this case, nonlocal is the closure variable and it is never reassigned; only its contents are changed. Other workarounds use lists or dictionaries.

Or you could use a class for the whole thing, as @naomik suggests in a comment. Define __call__() to make the instance callable.

class Foo(object):

    def __init__(self, counter=1):
       self.counter = counter

    def __call__(self):
       self.counter += 1
       print("bar", self.counter)

bar = Foo()
bar()

More Related Contents:

  1. A better way to write python closures? [closed]
  2. What do lambda function closures capture?
  3. Don’t understand why UnboundLocalError occurs (closure) [duplicate]
  4. Local variables in nested functions
  5. How are lambdas useful? [closed]
  6. How do lexical closures work?
  7. Python nonlocal statement
  8. How to understand closure in a lambda?
  9. Why aren’t python nested functions called closures?
  10. Python lambda’s binding to local values
  11. Python lambda closure scoping
  12. How do I create a list of lambdas (in a list comprehension/for loop)?
  13. Can you explain closures (as they relate to Python)?
  14. Why does this UnboundLocalError occur (closure)? [duplicate]
  15. nonlocal keyword in Python 2.x
  16. Read/Write Python Closures
  17. What limitations have closures in Python compared to language X closures?
  18. What exactly is contained within a obj.__closure__?
  19. Why results of map() and list comprehension are different? [duplicate]
  20. How to inject variable into scope with a decorator?
  21. How can a function access its own attributes?
  22. Python dynamic function creation with custom names
  23. Can you patch *just* a nested function with closure, or must the whole outer function be repeated?
  24. Weird closure behavior in python
  25. Python nonlocal statement / keyword
  26. Schrödinger’s variable: the __class__ cell magically appears if you’re checking for its presence?
  27. What does nonlocal do in Python 3?
  28. How do nested functions work in Python?
  29. Modify bound variables of a closure in Python
  30. How are python closures implemented?

Leave a Comment