Why should default parameters be added last in C++ functions?

by

To simplify the language definition and keep code readable.

void foo(int x = 2, int y);

To call that and take advantage of the default value, you’d need syntax like this:

foo(, 3);

Which was probably felt to be too weird. Another alternative is specifying names in the argument list:

foo(y : 3);

A new symbol would have to be used because this already means something:

foo(y = 3); // assign 3 to y and then pass y to foo.

The naming approach was considered and rejected by the ISO committee because they were uncomfortable with introducing a new significance to parameter names outside of the function definition.

If you’re interested in more C++ design rationales, read The Design and Evolution of C++ by Stroustrup.

More Related Contents:

  1. New to programming: How to call a structure’s variables in a function and then update them? (C++) [closed]
  2. Compilation error: expected constructor, destructor, or type conversion before ‘;’ token [closed]
  3. Return array in a function
  4. Using generic std::function objects with member functions in one class
  5. C++ callback using class member
  6. How to make a .lib file when have a .dll file and a header file
  7. How do you pass a member function pointer?
  8. C++ return array from function [duplicate]
  9. Why doesn’t C++ support functions returning arrays?
  10. Should I use an exception specifier in C++?
  11. When to Overload the Comma Operator?
  12. Why can’t we pass arrays to function by value?
  13. Inline function linkage
  14. Returning a pointer of a local variable C++
  15. C++ inline member function in .cpp file
  16. What is the meaning and usage of __stdcall?
  17. Function pointer vs Function reference
  18. How Non-Member Functions Improve Encapsulation
  19. Is it possible to std::move objects out of functions? (C++11)
  20. Simplest way to determine return type of function
  21. Do class functions/variables have to be declared before being used?
  22. how do I make a portable isnan/isinf function
  23. Set back default floating point print precision in C++
  24. Is a `=default` move constructor equivalent to a member-wise move constructor?
  25. Function in C++ returns by value or by reference?
  26. Why do we need to use `int main` and not `void main` in C++? [duplicate]
  27. Function to mangle/demangle functions
  28. How much overhead is there in calling a function in C++?
  29. is it possible to make function that will accept multiple data types for given argument?
  30. Get signatures of exported functions in a DLL

Leave a Comment