System.Web.Caching vs. Enterprise Library Caching Block

by

These are the items that I consider for the topic of Caching:

MemCached Win32
Velocity
.net Cache
Enterprise Library Caching Application Block

MemCached Win32: Up until recently I have used MemCached Win32. This is a akin to a web farm (many servers serving the same content for high availability) but it is a cache farm. This means that you can install it locally on your web server initially if you don’t have the resources to go bigger. Then as you go down the road you can scale horizontally (more servers) or vertically (more hardware). This is a product that was ported from the original MemCached to work on Windows. This product has been used extensively in very high traffic sites. http://lineofthought.com/tools/memcached

Velocity: This is Microsofts answer to products such as MemCached. MemCached has been out for quite some time, Velocity is in CTP mode. I must say that from what I have read so far this product will certainly turn my head once it is out. But I can’t bring myself to run big production projects on a CTP product with zero track record. I have started playing with it though as once it gains momentum MemCached won’t even compare for those locked in the windows world! http://blogs.msdn.com/velocity/

.NET Cache: There is no reason to discount the standard .NET Cache. It is built in and ready to use for free and with no (major) set up required. It offers flexibility by way of offering mechanisms for storing items in local memory, a SINGLE state server, or a centralized database. Where Velocity steps in is when you need more than a single state server (cache in memory) and don’t want to use a slow database for holding your cache.

Enterprise Application Block: I stay away from all of the Enterprise Application Blocks. They are heavy frameworks that give more than I generally require! As long as you remember to wrap everything that touches code that is not your own and follow simple rules for coding, stick to any of the other methods over this one! (just my opinion of course – MySpace leverages as much as they can out of Enterprise Application Blocks!)

You don’t have to choose up front! I generally create a cache wrapper that I communicate with in my code for methods such as Get, Set, Exists, Remove, ListKeys, etc. This then points to an underlying level of cache abstraction that can point to MemCached, Velocity, or .NET cache. I use StructureMap (or choose another IoC container) to inject which form of cache I want to use for a given environment. In my local dev box I might use .NET cache in the session. In production I generally use MemCached Win 32. But regardless of how it is set up you can easily swap things around to try each system out to see what works best for you. You just need to make sure that you application knows as little as possible about how things are cached! Once this layer of abstraction is in place you can then do things such as run a compression algorithm (gzip) for all the data that is going in and out of cache which would allow you to store 10 times the amount of data in cache. – transparently.

I cover .NET Cache, MemCached Win32, StructureMap, and the appropriate abstractions in my book if you are interested!

ASP.NET 3.5 Social Networking (http://www.amazon.com/ASP-NET-3-5-Social-Networking-Enterprise-ready/dp/1847194788/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1225408005&sr=8-1 )
Andrew Siemer www.andrewsiemer.com blog.andrewsiemer.com www.socialnetworkingin.net

Update
Changed the link that lists sites using memcached. Thank you David for noticing that it was broken!

More Related Contents:

  1. Memcached vs. Redis? [closed]
  2. Best way of creating a record cache ( Memcache in this example ) [closed]
  3. Why is the size of L1 cache smaller than that of the L2 cache in most of the processors?
  4. How to cache Google map tiles for offline usage?
  5. AngularJS disable partial caching on dev machine
  6. Line size of L1 and L2 caches
  7. Memcached vs APC which one should I choose? [closed]
  8. Better Way to Prevent IE Cache in AngularJS?
  9. Chrome doesn’t cache images/js/css
  10. How does one write code that best utilizes the CPU cache to improve performance?
  11. VIPT Cache: Connection between TLB & Cache?
  12. Redis: possible to expire an element in an array or sorted set?
  13. What does it mean by cold cache and warm cache concept?
  14. How to force browsers to reload cached CSS and JS files?
  15. Tomcat 8 throwing – org.apache.catalina.webresources.Cache.getResource Unable to add the resource
  16. Difference between no-cache and must-revalidate for Cache-Control?
  17. Redis cache vs using memory directly
  18. Write-back vs Write-Through caching?
  19. What’s default value of cache-control?
  20. Caching Data in Web API
  21. how to release the caching which is used by Mongodb?
  22. How does Linux perf calculate the cache-references and cache-misses events
  23. WP7 HttpWebRequest without caching
  24. How to clear CPU L1 and L2 cache [duplicate]
  25. How to prevent Browser cache on Angular 2 site?
  26. RAM drive for compiling – is there such a thing?
  27. alternative to memcached that can persist to disk
  28. Virtually indexed physically tagged cache Synonym
  29. When does browser automatically clear cache of external JavaScript file?
  30. Using cache in ExoPlayer

Leave a Comment